top of page

IRマガジンに掲載されました。
代表の杉渕が日本企業のガバナンス改革の現状についいてコメントしました

グローバルIR業界の機関紙であるIRマガジンより、日本企業のガバナンスについてインタビューされました。以下は英語での原文です。



Nintendo Switch success drives governance questionsMAR 02, 2018Development highlights remaining questions around Japanese corporate governance

Nintendo’s share price is at a near-10 year high, topping ¥48,000 ($449) – but the company faces questions over its corporate governance.

The boost to the Kyoto, Japan-headquartered company’s stock comes off the back of the huge success of its Switch console, which has sold more than 12 mn units since its launch in March last year. But its success is pricing out many retail investors because of a minimum trading limit of 100 shares, with both CNBC and the Financial Times reporting that some investors are calling for a stock split to widen the shareholder base and aid governance.

The FT quotes Macquarie analyst David Gibson as saying a stock split would be ‘a good first step’ toward greater transparency, while on CNBC Atul Goyal of Jefferies discusses the governance implications of such a move.

According to data from Morningstar, the firm did split its stock once, in 1989, with a 3:2 ratio.

‘Nintendo is notorious for bad IR,’ Hitoshi Sugibuchi, representative director at governance and IR consultant Sessa Partners, tells IR Magazine. ‘Nintendo does not attend brokers’ conferences, doesn’t do overseas roadshows or even conference calls. It accepts meetings only with investors that come to its headquarters in Kyoto, and then with a limited time window.’

A request for comment from Nintendo was not returned within 24 hours. This article will be updated with comments if received.

There are signs the firm is becoming more transparent, however. In his most recent statement to shareholders, company president Tatsumi Kimishima announced plans to widen access to Nintendo’s intellectual property with plans for everything from gaming cards to theme parks and a new Mario film being made with Illumination Entertainment, the US film and animation studio behind Despicable Me.

‘Not many investors criticize Nintendo because of its unique business domain,’ Sugibuchi continues. ‘Although gaming is a large industry, the business culture and management style is quite different compared with other sectors. The drivers are creators and engineers whose incentives are interest and curiosity rather than money. Nintendo has created its own management way and operational policy, and many investors respect this even though some complain about poor disclosure.’

Governance review

Japan introduced a new corporate governance code in 2014, but there are concerns that governance has remained a box-ticking exercise at some firms. That said, Sugibuchi notes that 98 percent of the JPX-Nikkei 400 now has two or more outside directors, as required by the code. This is an increase from 21 percent before the code came into force.

Outside directors are not having the desired impact at Japanese companies in general. ‘High levels of retained cash in company balance sheets, low dividend-payout ratios and a slow pace on the unwinding of cross-shareholdings [where the company owns shares in a partner firm]’ are all adding to these concerns, Sugibuchi adds. ‘The first step in the introduction of outside directors is over,’ he says. ‘Our focus from now on is how outside directors work, monitoring the board and even confronting the CEO if necessary.’

Japan’s Financial Services Agency (FSA) is now preparing to revise and strengthen the existing code, which also allows companies to switch to a new governance structure by appointing statutory auditors as outside directors.

This is something Nintendo has taken advantage of, with all three of the firm’s outside directors having previously served as Nintendo auditors. Such individuals would not be considered independent directors in other jurisdictions, and their appointment is therefore unlikely to impress foreign investors. Sugibuchi notes that such moves are little reported on within Japan, partly because the practice is allowed under the code but also because, even in the media, there is ‘not a good understanding of corporate governance.’

The FSA is expected to publish its draft statement for changes to the code in June, with CEO performance, appointment and termination among other issues on the agenda. But Sugibuchi says it is companies’ philosophy that needs to change. ‘Traditionally, Japanese people respect seniority,’ he explains. ‘Thus, CEOs have strong leadership and board members will not strongly oppose them. But board members should understand that they work for the shareholders, not the CEO.’

The role of investors

As well as the introduction of the corporate governance code, 2014 also saw the FSA introduce a stewardship code to promote greater dialogue between investors and companies and push for governance reform – but again, progress has been slow.

‘There wasn’t much improvement in terms of the relationship between the buy side and companies in the first few years,’ Sugibuchi notes. In a renewed push last year, the government called on asset management firms to disclose their voting records at annual meetings, something the majority of asset management firms have now begun to do.

Japan’s Government Pension Investment Fund (GPIF) – the world’s largest pension fund with assets of around ¥162.67 tn as of September 2017 – has been increasingly focusing on governance. It does not invest directly in equities but via asset managers and ‘in order to improve productivity in the private sector, GPIF is demanding that asset managers build engagement with corporate management,’ says Sugibuchi. ‘It has a strong influence in the investment world, and its current focuses are corporate governance and ESG.’

In July 2017 MSCI launched two new ESG-focused indexes aimed at Japanese companies: the MSCI Japan Empowering Women Index and the MSCI Japan ESG Select Leaders Index, with the GPIF.

The country is also seeing a slight increase in shareholder activism, Sugibuchi adds. For example, GPIF has invested in Taiyo Pacific, a US activist fund targeting Japanese companies. Still, ‘Japanese institutional investors are reluctant to ally with aggressive foreign investors,’ Sugibuchi says, adding that if a campaign became a proxy fight at the AGM, ‘it seems unlikely minority shareholders could beat company management without teaming up with domestic investors.’

He says public campaigns are ­likely to have more of an impact as Japanese management values reputation.


2018年3月11日

最新の投稿

2026年11月19日

台北ノンディール・ロードショー ― 存在感を増す台湾の機関投資家

久しぶりに台北でノンディール・ロードショーを行いました。台湾の機関投資家の構造、進む金融グループの統合、高まる日本株への関心、そして台北NDRの現地メモをお届けします。

2026年11月6日

【お知らせ】スポンサードリサーチ(SIR)レポートの「note」公式ページ掲載開始について

〜AI検索・テキスト分析に対応し、企業価値のさらなる認知向上へ〜 平素は格別のご高配を賜り、厚く御礼申し上げます。 独立系リサーチ・IR支援を手掛けるSESSAパートナーズは、このたび提供中の「スポンサードリサーチ(SIR)レポート」につきまして、従来の配信網に加え、新たに公式「note」への掲載を開始いたしました。 ■ 公式noteページ https://note.com/sessair ■ note掲載開始の背景:変化する情報探索スタイルへの対応 これまで弊社では、レイアウトの美しさや印刷・保存時の可読性を重視し、主に「PDF形式」にて高品質なアナリストレポートをお届けしてまいりました。 しかし昨今、生成AIを活用した検索やテキスト分析ツールの急速な普及に伴い、企業情報の「構造化テキストデータ」としてのアクセス需要が急速に高まっています。 Web上で直接読み取れるテキスト形式で情報を提供することにより、以下の価値創出を目指します。 1. AI・検索エンジンへのインデックス最適化 Web検索やAI検索経由での情報キャッチアップ精度が向上し、潜在的な投資家へのリーチを拡大します。...

2026年10月8日

AIRMAN (6364)のリサーチカバレッジを開始しました

事業概要 AIRMANはコンプレッサ技術を中核とする建設機械・産業機械メーカーである。主力のエンジンコンプレッサは国内シェア1位、世界シェア2位を誇り、発電機や高所作業車などでも高い市場地位を有している。2025年には長年使用してきた「北越工業」から「AIRMAN」へ社名変更を実施し、グローバルブランドの統一を図った。 注目点 北米市場向けのエンジンコンプレッサおよび発電機の販売が大幅に伸長し、2027/3期Q1は大幅増益となった。これを受け、通期営業利益予想を5,630百万円から8,300百万円へ47.4%上方修正した。今後は、北米市場の好調が持続するかに加え、低迷する北米以外の海外市場の回復、価格改定による収益性向上の継続が注目される。 https://www.sessapartners.co.jp/research-report/airman

contact_visual.jpg

お問い合わせ

Contact

電話またはメールでいつでもお気軽にお問い合わせください

bottom of page